For a director long infested with and invested in deep-seated anxieties about the relationship between perturbed men and the women they feel entitled to and mortified about, Dead Ringers reflects David Cronenberg simultaneously at his most hesitant and exploratory, both empowered over his subject and emasculated by it. On “empowered”, Dead Ringers is the product of significant confidence, the director emboldened by the success of his prior film The Fly, which was the inflection point between his gutter-limned, filthy body horror films and his more intellectually-charged Hollywood productions drawing on blood veins of Shakespearean tragedy and classical literature.
At the same time, Dead Ringers’ attitudes toward sex lack the primal sensibilities of his earlier films. It feels evolved, civilized, and in some small way, sadly domesticated, like it needs to justify itself by being about something rather than simply being something. As good as Dead Ringers is, it also spends the entire film looking over its shoulder just to make sure it isn’t being followed by the specter of Cronenberg’s more brutal earlier exploitation films, themselves infused with the confidence to tackle issues without so obviously TACKLING ISSUES. Although Cronenberg obviously feels liberated to dissect fanatically adult issues, he also feels too cautious and manicured in his approach to really vivisect sexual competition and power at the root and explore the innards of the male ego in all their writhing, bloody anti-glory. It’s not exactly timid, but the film suffers from ruminations that only ever bore half-way into the skull. Continue reading →