Ride the Pink Horse is a film noir about a man who travels to a small desert town at the border of the U.S. and Mexico only to find that he is vastly in over his head. The location is in no way incidental to the film’s vision. What we might call “desert noir” – films like Billy Wilder’s Ace in the Hole (1951) Edgar Ulmer’s Detour (1945), and (admittedly stretching the “noir” claim) John Huston’s The Treasure of the Sierra Madre (1948) – turns away from the noir’s typical haunting ground of the modern city to frame the desert as a limbo for wayward souls. While Old Hollywood Westerns often centered their moral universes around pioneering egos heroically exploring unseen frontiers, bringing light to the proverbial shadows, mid-century film noirs often shadowed the visible with intimations of vaster conspiracies and relations stringing humans along while slowly sucking them dry. To combine the two genres, to infest the Western with the blood of film noir, is to offer a curdled critique of America’s pretensions of access to possibility (monetary or otherwise) stolen from the land. Rather than celebrating divine effusion, these films bear witness to modern America’s demonic extraction, taking an outward violence and turning it back inward onto the soul. They turn the West that was perceived as a hinterland of possibility into a moral quagmire, one in which fantasies of Promethean overcoming within an unfashioned expanse come home to roost.
In this spirit, Robert Montgomery’s Ride the Pink Horse (1947) is a film about a man who is aspiring well beyond his means, travelling farther than he really can walk, to acquire something he doesn’t really understand. This was Montgomery’s second noir, a seeming step back from the bravura formal experimentation of his debut, a film shot entirely from the first-perspective of its protagonist that remains a watermark for the idea of the actor turned director. The protagonist of Lady in the Lake was none other than Raymond Chandler’s Philip Marlowe, the curdled noir hero par excellence, a figure evaporated but also oddly elevated and aggrandized by a camera that can’t even see him. The character is voiced by Montgomery himself, and not only are we trapped in his perspective, but he remains the film’s ultimate shadow. With Montgomery behind the director’s chair and the film directed by Marlowe’s own vision, entirely defined by where he looks, the protagonist becomes both a ghostly passenger in a narrative he can’t control and the ultimate director, a never-visible puppeteer behind the camera who can see literally everything we see.
Ride the Pink Horse isn’t as formally audacious, but it may, if anything, be more troubling, challenging, and sophisticated in the way it merges its style and its exploration of mid-century masculinity in the texture of its narrative. Montgomery again plays the protagonist here in addition to directing the film, and there’s a vestigial sense of the former film’s POV in the opaque angles Montgomery shoots himself from. Deemphasizing him in the space, the film draws us in to his limits, to his inability to center or command the frame that is supposed to legitimize his story. This is a thread that culminates in a deliriously thorny and self-debasing conclusion in which the nominal hero is rendered compliant and incapacitated before the villains. In a totally, defiantly egoless move on Montgomery’s part, he is saved at the last minute, through no skill of his own, by a man we aren’t meant to trust who talks and acts like a muppet.
Continue reading









