
Update early 2019: The original Alien is such an incredible exercise in negative space and sonic absence, an unwelcoming dispatch from an all-too-fathomable future, a transmission from the dark side of the 1970s that pushes the haunted house film to its constitutive limits. Scott’s attempts to expand the mythology here misfire on all counts, only diffusing the purity with a kind of thematic dilettantism – a little Bible here, some Greek mythology there – as though the screenwriters were afraid that anything other than reconsidering the entire Western canon would be a failure of ambition. That original film remains a stark howl of cinematic minimalism, a fugitive, monstrous insurgent into the increasingly grand and self-important cinematic landscape of the late ’70s, but this new one just replicates the grand, Gothic tendentiousness of every other blockbuster film in the 2010s, all sound and fury signifying ego.
Original Review
Alien3 was its gloomy adolescent faze. Alien: Resurrection was it mid-life crisis where it put on a clown costume and rode around on a fluorescent motorcycle to prove its hipness. The AVP films are the lost years. And Prometheus was a kind of rebirth, a newfound, new-agey euphoria where intelligence and pseudo-intelligence intermixed to the point of abject indecipherability. But what does that make Covenant for the Alien franchise?
A film that is usually unsure of itself, above all, one which tries to repeat and reconcile the entire franchise in the course of one film. One that struggles to decipher some point of solubility for many films and as many essentially irreconcilable viewpoints about cinema and the world. In this series of films whose entries have uniquely little tonally or atmospherically to say to one another, Covenant is also a return to the good old days, a regression, and a stasis of sorts, an attempt to retain and harden the philosophical musings of Prometheus while finding salvation through a return to the franchise’s younger days of cold-blooded, efficient brutality. To fossilize what intelligence the at-least self-consciously oblique Prometheus had for fear of it slipping away and to efface that intelligence by cutting through the fat with a lean, mean monster film, a marriage of pulp and phenomenology that just does not mix. As if afraid to acknowledge that less can be more, director Ridley Scott demands to be taken seriously as an auteur, which for him, means thematizing and seeking solace in headiness with a capital-H even when it is to the detriment of the overall production. As a down-and-dirty horror film, Covenant is retreading old ground, sure, but doing so with gusto and panache. As a rambling monologue (or dialogue, I suppose) about the nature of creation, creator, and created, it’s just another patch on the quilt proving that these pseudo-pretentious sci-fi action films have nothing new to say about their robot fetish. Continue reading →