In the spirit of reviewing things other than obscure horror films from the ’80s, I’ll be spending the next few weeks dusting off some less eldritch cinematic creatures from the long-ago year of 2019, a uniquely intriguing year for the cinema and the final year before the industry took an extended hiatus for reasons I do not have to clarify.
In the beginning, there is only a boat clarifying its way out of the foggy sea, a speck of uncertainty coagulating its way out of the graininess of the film stock. The Lighthouse begins in the ether, in other words, with a material thing etching itself out of the two nebulous spaces we call the ocean and cinema. Over the subsequent 100 minutes, David Eggers’ film will stage and then vandalize the attempt to escape it. Finally, the belief in the distinctly human attempt to solidify stable things, to escape the all-consuming and finally formless world we come from and will return to, becomes a cruel trick of the gods. The Lighthouse is an otherworld, a confounding out-of-the-way that is also, in its overflowing sensory exertions and heaving presences, an all-around-us. It’s always there, an omnipresent sensorial experience. But it also feels like it is perpetually drifting into nothingness. It is both a force and a void of a film, a dimly visible but often sensible appreciation for the unclarifiable. As a film, it’s everywhere, on all sides of us, but you get the sense that you see it less than it can see you. The boat will deliver two men to a lighthouse off the coast of New England. It also delivers the strangest of dispatches to us.
The Lighthouse is a horror film of the mind and the body. It has as much in common with Tarkovsky as Cronenberg. It’s a spiritual lament, but also a corporeal act, a film in which places, machines, and bodies require upkeep, in which mending and releasing are acts of the flesh, the mind, and the spirit. The light of the lighthouse the two men operate is a terrible siren beckoning the soul to its furthest reaches, but it also needs oil to keep running. The cistern of drinkable water looks like celestial sludge, but it also needs to be churned. The film’s soundscape (by sound designer Damian Volpe and composer Mark Korven) is thoroughly otherworldly, but it also must make due with Willem Dafoe’s perennial farts. And a peek from above into a bedroom offers a writhing intimation of a body that might be engaging in some eldritch ritual of cosmic undoing, but it’s probably just the more everyday unknowable of masturbation behind a closed door. A seagull is an omen of ill intent and an unthinkable cosmos, but it’s also a blank thing that just doesn’t care about us that much, and doesn’t really want to bear the weight of our symbolic readings of it.
Continue reading









